Few things feel more like a classic Wildwood summer than walking into a busy family restaurant, hearing the chatter around you, and knowing there is a giant ice cream sundae waiting at the end of the meal. That is the appeal of Duffer’s. It is not just a place to grab dessert; it combines a full restaurant, homemade ice cream parlor, take-out service, arcade, mini golf, and a distinctly old-fashioned family atmosphere.
If you are searching for the duffer’s restaurant & old fashioned ice cream parlor menu, you are probably trying to answer a practical question: What can I actually order here, how much does it cost, and what is worth trying?
The good news is that the menu covers a lot of ground. You can stop in for breakfast, order a burger or sandwich for lunch, sit down for dinner, or skip straight to one of the oversized ice cream creations. Duffer’s official site says the restaurant has served Wildwood since 1974 and remains family owned and operated. Dduffers+1
This guide breaks down the menu by meal, explains the dessert choices, highlights popular options, discusses current prices where they are available, and gives practical tips for families planning a visit.
Duffer’s Restaurant & Old Fashioned Ice Cream Parlor Menu Overview
Duffer’s is located at 5210 Pacific Avenue in Wildwood, New Jersey, and its menu is much broader than the name might suggest. The restaurant serves breakfast, lunch, dinner, children’s meals, and a large selection of homemade ice cream desserts. Dduffers
The current online ordering menu groups the food into several categories:
- Beverages
- Appetizers
- Soup and salads
- Steak sandwiches
- Chicken and fish sandwiches
- Wrap-A-Rounds
- Gourmet burgers and hot dogs
- Deli sandwiches
- Dinners
- Sides and extras
- Cups and cones
- Hot fudge sundaes
- Special sundaes
- Old-fashioned sundaes
- Splits, waffles, and pie
- Ice cream toppings SSpotOn Order
That variety makes Duffer’s particularly useful for groups. One person can order a burger, another can choose seafood, a child can pick something simple, and everyone can finish with ice cream.
There is also a separate take-out area at the corner of Hildreth and Pacific Avenues. The restaurant says customers can order in person, call ahead, or order online for pickup. Dduffers
Duffer’s Breakfast Menu and Morning Favorites
Breakfast is one of the reasons Duffer’s works as more than an ice cream stop.
The restaurant describes its breakfast menu as including homemade stuffed French toast, homemade waffles with ice cream, chipped beef, fresh omelets, and other breakfast choices. Dduffers
That combination gives you two very different ways to approach breakfast.
If you want a traditional morning meal, an omelet or savory breakfast is the sensible choice. If you are on vacation and want to fully embrace the Wildwood experience, waffles with ice cream are considerably more indulgent.
Stuffed French toast is another standout for anyone who prefers a sweet breakfast. It makes sense for families because breakfast can feel like an event rather than simply a quick meal.
A practical tip: check the current menu before visiting if you have your heart set on one particular breakfast item. Seasonal restaurant menus can change, and online listings do not always update at exactly the same time.
For a family with mixed tastes, breakfast at Duffer’s can be easier than finding a separate breakfast restaurant and dessert stop later in the day.
Duffer’s Lunch Menu: Sandwiches, Burgers, and More
The lunch side of the menu is built around familiar American comfort food, which makes it easy to find something for nearly everyone.
The official restaurant description mentions appetizers, wraps, steak sandwiches, burgers, fresh salads, and dinner-style specials. Dduffers
The current online menu also lists chicken and fish sandwiches, deli sandwiches, gourmet burgers and hot dogs, and several other categories. SSpotOn Order
Some current online menu examples include:
- Grilled chicken sandwich
- Chicken cutlet club
- Chicken Parm sandwich
- Crab cake sandwich
- Fresh flounder sandwich
- Grilled chicken avocado sandwich
- Salmon ABLT
- Reuben
- Hot roast beef
- Double-decker club
- BLT
- Tuna melt
- Grilled cheese
- Chicken salad sandwich
- Turkey breast sandwich SSpotOn Order
This is where Duffer’s becomes particularly convenient for families. You do not need everyone to want the same style of food.
If you want something filling but not overly heavy before a long afternoon at the beach, a grilled chicken sandwich or salad can make more sense than a large dessert. If you have spent the day walking the boardwalk and want something substantial, a burger, steak sandwich, or dinner entrée may be the better fit.
Duffer’s Appetizers and Shareable Food
Appetizers can be useful when several people want to share something before their main meals.
The current online menu lists choices such as Freedom Fries, Buffalo Bites, nachos, chicken fingers, fried mozzarella, chicken quesadilla, onion rings, French fries, cheese fries, a crab cake starter, and a Bavarian-style pretzel. SSpotOn Order
For a group, sharing an appetizer can be smarter than ordering several large starters.
The Nacho Supreme, for example, combines tortilla chips with melted Jack and cheddar cheese, roasted corn, black bean salsa, green onions, jalapeños, and sour cream. Grilled chicken or pulled pork can be added for an additional charge. SSpotOn Order
The crab cake starter takes a different approach, pairing a lump crab cake with roasted corn, black bean salsa, and chipotle cream. SSpotOn Order
If you are planning to order a large sundae afterward, consider sharing an appetizer instead of ordering one for every person. Duffer’s dessert portions can be substantial, so leaving room is worthwhile.
Duffer’s Steak Sandwiches and Classic Sandwich Choices
Steak sandwiches are another useful section for anyone looking for a hearty meal without ordering a full dinner entrée.
The online menu currently lists plain steak, cheese steak, chicken cheese steak, pizza steak, “The Works,” and bacon cheese steak. SSpotOn Order
“The Works” adds cheese, sweet peppers, mushrooms, and fried onions, while the bacon cheese steak combines bacon and cheese with the steak. SSpotOn Order
The best choice depends on how hungry you are.
A plain steak sandwich keeps things straightforward. A cheese steak is the familiar middle ground. The Works is the choice for someone who likes a more loaded sandwich.
For younger diners or lighter appetites, the deli sandwich section gives you simpler alternatives such as grilled cheese, turkey, tuna salad, chicken salad, and BLT options. SSpotOn Order
This variety is one of the menu’s strengths: you can build a meal around what you actually want rather than forcing yourself into one restaurant style.
Duffer’s Chicken and Seafood Menu
Duffer’s also offers several chicken and seafood choices, which can be helpful when someone in your group does not want a burger or steak sandwich.
The current menu includes grilled chicken, chicken cutlet dishes, chicken Parm, crab cake, fresh flounder, salmon, and fish-based tacos. SSpotOn Order
The Fresh Flounder Sandwich is described as lightly breaded and deep fried, then served with lettuce, tomato, and melted cheese on a soft roll. SSpotOn Order
The Salmon ABLT takes a more substantial approach, pairing grilled salmon with avocado, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and chipotle mayonnaise on toasted country white bread. SSpotOn Order
For seafood lovers, the menu provides more than one direction. You can keep it casual with a sandwich or choose a dinner entrée if you want a larger meal.
One useful tip is to look at the day’s specials as well. Duffer’s official site says its dinner menu includes homemade dinner specials, so the regular online menu may not tell the whole story. Dduffers
Duffer’s Dinner Menu and Evening Meals
Dinner is where Duffer’s moves beyond the typical boardwalk snack menu.
The restaurant advertises cooked-to-order dinner and nightly specials, along with steaks, ribs, seafood, sandwiches, burgers, salads, and other comfort-food choices. Dduffers+1
That makes it possible to have a complete meal without treating the restaurant as only an ice cream parlor.
For families, this can be a major advantage. Parents can order a full dinner while children choose familiar items from the children’s menu.
Duffer’s also notes that parties larger than six may be split between two booths, and guests must be present in person to add their name to the waitlist. The restaurant does not take reservations. Dduffers
If you are visiting during a busy summer evening, plan accordingly.
A smart strategy is to arrive earlier than the peak dinner rush. You can also consider take-out if you want to avoid waiting for a table.
Duffer’s Ice Cream Flavors and Homemade Dessert Menu
This is the section many visitors are really searching for.
Duffer’s says its homemade ice cream is made daily on the premises and highlights its large sundaes, banana splits, waffles with ice cream, milkshakes, and ice cream sodas. Dduffers
The online menu currently offers cups, cones, hot fudge sundaes, special sundaes, old-fashioned sundaes, splits, waffles, pie, and extra toppings. SSpotOn Order
A current menu listing includes flavors such as:
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
- Coffee
- Chocolate chip
- Mint chocolate chip
- Cookie dough
- Butter pecan
- Butter almond
- Butter brickle
- Maple walnut
- Pistachio
- Rocky Road
- Pralines and cream
- Rum raisin
- Peanut butter swirl
- Oreo cookie
- Strawberry cheesecake
- Peach
- Cherry vanilla
- Coconut chip
- Chocolate peanut butter swirl RRestaurant Guru
The available flavor selection can change, so do not assume every flavor will be available on every visit.
Duffer’s also lists non-dairy and frozen-yogurt choices in its menu information, although the exact selection can vary. RRestaurant Guru
If you are visiting with a large group, choosing different flavors and sharing a sundae can be more fun than everyone ordering the same thing.
Duffer’s Cups, Cones, and Simple Ice Cream Orders
Not everyone wants an enormous sundae.
Sometimes you just want a scoop of ice cream after dinner, and Duffer’s offers straightforward cup and cone options.
The current online ordering menu lists:
- Kid cone
- Single cone
- Double cone
- Kid cup
- Single cup
- Double cup
- Quart of ice cream SSpotOn Order
Current listed prices are $6.95 for a kid cone or cup, $8.15 for a single cone or cup, $9.15 for a double cone or cup, and $12.50 for a quart. SSpotOn Order
Prices can change, so treat these as the prices shown on the current online ordering menu rather than a permanent price guarantee.
A simple scoop is actually a smart choice if you have already eaten a full dinner. It lets you experience the homemade ice cream without committing to a huge dessert.
For children, the kid-size option can also make sense when a full sundae would be too much.
Duffer’s Old Fashioned Sundaes
The old-fashioned sundae section is where the restaurant’s nostalgic personality really comes through.
One of the current choices is the Old Fashioned Split, which includes a whole banana, three giant scoops of homemade vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate ice cream, chocolate syrup, strawberries, pineapple topping, whipped cream, and a cherry. The current listed price is $14.75. SSpotOn Order
That is not a small dessert.
It is designed for someone who wants the full classic ice cream-parlor experience.
Duffer’s also offers several hot fudge and specialty creations. The Original Hot Fudge Sundae, for example, combines homemade vanilla ice cream with hot fudge, pure whipped cream, and a cherry. SSpotOn Order
If you are visiting for the first time, the classic options are a good starting point. You can always experiment with more elaborate combinations on a future trip.
And if you are eating dinner first, consider sharing. Two people can often enjoy a large sundae without feeling that they need to finish every topping.
Duffer’s Signature Hot Fudge Sundaes
Hot fudge is one of the easiest ways to understand why Duffer’s dessert menu is such a major part of the restaurant experience.
The current menu includes options such as Double Stuffed Fudge, Banana Fudge Royal, Nacho Average Sundae, Pretzel Fudge, PB & Bananas, Here Comes Fudge, Original Hot Fudge, and Reese’s Fudge. SSpotOn Order
The Double Stuffed Fudge is built around Oreo ice cream, hot fudge, marshmallow cream, Oreo pieces, whipped cream, and a cherry. The Banana Fudge Royal combines vanilla ice cream with banana slices, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. SSpotOn Order
For peanut butter fans, the PB & Bananas combines vanilla ice cream, Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups, bananas, hot fudge, whipped cream, and a cherry. SSpotOn Order
These are indulgent desserts, and that is the point.
If you want something more balanced, choose a simple scoop or a smaller sundae. If you are celebrating a birthday or ending a big family dinner, one of the larger creations makes much more sense.
Duffer’s Waffles, Splits, and Pie
Duffer’s dessert menu goes beyond ice cream in a cone.
The current online menu includes several waffle creations, banana splits, and pie. SSpotOn Order
The Belgian Waffle Sundae combines a Belgian waffle with ice cream, whipped cream, and a cherry. The Ultimate Waffle adds vanilla ice cream, hot caramel, hot fudge, Heath Bar pieces, whipped cream, and a cherry. SSpotOn Order
The Waffles Foster takes another route, combining a Belgian waffle with vanilla ice cream, warm caramel, banana slices, roasted pecans, whipped cream, and a cherry. SSpotOn Order
There is also an Old Fashioned Split and a Hot Fudge Split. For something less complicated, the menu lists Hot Apple Pie A La Mode with vanilla ice cream. SSpotOn Order
If you are trying to choose between a sundae and waffle, think about texture.
Sundaes are mostly creamy and saucy. Waffles add a warm, buttery element. That contrast can make a waffle dessert feel more like a complete after-dinner treat.
Duffer’s Prices: What Should You Budget?
Menu prices are one of the most important reasons people search for a restaurant menu before visiting.
The current online ordering menu provides useful examples. For instance, single cups and cones are listed at $8.15, double cups and cones at $9.15, and several large specialty sundaes fall in the $12–$17 range. SSpotOn Order
Current examples include:
- Original Hot Fudge Sundae: $12.25
- Strawberry Stack: $13.25
- Chocolate Banana Sundae: $12.95
- Old Fashioned Split: $14.75
- Peanut Blast Split: $15.95
- Belgian Waffle Sundae: $14.95
- Ultimate Waffle: $16.95
- Waffles Foster: $16.95 SSpotOn Order
Food prices vary by category, with sandwiches, appetizers, seafood, burgers, and dinner items occupying different price ranges. SSpotOn Order
Because restaurant prices can change during the season, check the current online ordering menu before budgeting for a large group.
Also remember that a giant dessert can easily become a shared experience. If four people each order an elaborate sundae, the total bill rises quickly. Ordering two large desserts for the table may be a better strategy.
What Should You Order at Duffer’s?
If you are visiting for the first time, your order should depend on what you want from the experience.
For a classic ice cream stop, try a simple homemade flavor or an Original Hot Fudge Sundae.
For a group, the Old Fashioned Split is a natural choice because it combines several classic flavors and toppings in one dessert. SSpotOn Order
For chocolate lovers, Double Stuffed Fudge or Reese’s Fudge offers a much richer experience. SSpotOn Order
For someone who wants a warm dessert element, Waffles Foster or the Ultimate Waffle is worth considering. SSpotOn Order
For a lighter finish after dinner, order a single scoop.
For lunch, a grilled chicken sandwich, burger, steak sandwich, or seafood sandwich gives you a more substantial meal.
And for families with different preferences, do not overthink it. Duffer’s broad menu is designed around variety.
Duffer’s Take-Out Menu and Online Ordering
Sometimes you want the food without committing to a full sit-down meal.
Duffer’s operates a separate take-out area on the corner of Hildreth and Pacific Avenues. The restaurant says customers can order in person, call ahead, or use online ordering. Dduffers
The take-out menu includes food as well as homemade ice cream, sundaes, cones, cups, milkshakes, waffles, and splits. Dduffers
This option can be particularly useful for families with tired children or anyone who has already spent hours at the beach.
There is one important detail to remember: items purchased through the take-out area are not permitted inside the dining room. The restaurant provides an outdoor bench area on a first-come, first-served basis for enjoying take-out treats. Dduffers
If you want full table service, order inside instead.
If speed matters more than sitting down, the take-out window may be the better choice.
Visiting Duffer’s With Kids and Families
Duffer’s is clearly built around family entertainment.
The restaurant says it offers a children’s menu, while the overall property also includes an arcade, an 18-hole miniature golf course, and a gift shop. Dduffers
That combination makes the location more than a restaurant stop. Families can turn dinner and dessert into part of a larger evening.
The children’s menu is especially useful because adults can order from the main menu while younger diners have simpler choices.
There is also a practical stroller restriction to know before arriving. Duffer’s states that strollers are not permitted in the dining room because of safety and insurance regulations. Dduffers
If you are traveling with a baby or toddler, plan around that rule.
For large families, it is also worth knowing that parties over six may be split between two booths, according to the restaurant’s current information. Dduffers
That detail can prevent surprises when you arrive.
Duffer’s Atmosphere, Location, and What to Expect
The experience is intentionally nostalgic.
Duffer’s describes its setting as a Victorian atmosphere and has operated in Wildwood since 1974. Dduffers+1
The atmosphere is not designed to feel like a quiet, minimalist restaurant. It is a family-oriented destination with food, ice cream, games, mini golf, and plenty happening around you.
That distinction matters when deciding whether it is right for your evening.
If you want a lively family outing, the atmosphere can be part of the fun. If you are looking for a quiet romantic dinner, the combination of families, arcade activity, and dessert traffic may not be your ideal setting.
The location at 5210 Pacific Avenue also makes it convenient for visitors exploring Wildwood. Dduffers
Before visiting, check the restaurant’s official site for the latest hours and seasonal information. The restaurant operates seasonally and currently lists an opening around Memorial Day weekend. Dduffers
Tips for Getting the Most From the Duffer’s Menu
A little planning can make the visit much easier.
First, decide whether your priority is a meal, ice cream, or both. If dessert is the main attraction, you may not want a huge lunch beforehand.
Second, check the current menu and prices online before leaving. The official ordering system provides current menu categories and prices, while seasonal availability can change. SSpotOn Order
Third, think about sharing large desserts. The specialty sundaes, splits, and waffles are designed to be substantial.
Fourth, consider take-out during a busy visit. Duffer’s provides a dedicated pickup area with in-person, phone, and online ordering. Dduffers
Finally, do not judge the menu only by its ice cream selection. Duffer’s offers enough breakfast, lunch, dinner, seafood, sandwiches, and comfort food to make a full meal worthwhile. Dduffers
The biggest mistake is arriving without a plan when you have a large family and everyone is hungry. Spend two minutes looking over the menu beforehand. It can save time and make ordering much less chaotic.
Conclusion
The appeal of Duffer’s comes from its combination of food and nostalgia.
You can walk in for breakfast, stop by for a casual lunch, have a family dinner, or skip the meal and head straight for homemade ice cream. The menu covers familiar American favorites while the dessert side gives the restaurant its real personality.
The standout feature is clearly the ice cream experience. Duffer’s makes homemade ice cream on the premises and offers everything from simple cones and cups to huge sundaes, splits, waffles, and other elaborate creations. Dduffers+1
For first-time visitors, I would keep the strategy simple: choose a meal that fits your appetite, save room for dessert, and consider sharing one of the larger creations.
And if you are visiting with children, leave enough time to enjoy the other attractions. The arcade and 18-hole mini golf course are part of what makes Duffer’s different from an ordinary neighborhood ice cream shop. Dduffers
Most importantly, remember that menus and prices can change. The official Duffer’s website and online ordering menu are the best places to check current offerings before you go. Dduffers+1
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where is Duffer’s Restaurant & Old Fashioned Ice Cream Parlor?
Duffer’s is located at 5210 Pacific Avenue in Wildwood, New Jersey. The restaurant’s listed phone number is (609) 729-1817. Dduffers
2. What kind of food does Duffer’s serve?
Duffer’s serves breakfast, lunch, dinner, appetizers, sandwiches, burgers, seafood, salads, children’s meals, and homemade ice cream desserts. Its menu is designed to accommodate both full meals and casual dessert visits. Dduffers+1
3. Does Duffer’s really make its own ice cream?
Duffer’s states that its homemade ice cream is made daily on the premises. The restaurant offers cones, cups, sundaes, banana splits, waffles with ice cream, milkshakes, and ice cream sodas. Dduffers
4. How much does ice cream cost at Duffer’s?
The current online ordering menu lists a kid cone or cup at $6.95, a single cone or cup at $8.15, and a double cone or cup at $9.15. Specialty desserts currently range from roughly $12 to $17, depending on the item. SSpotOn Order
Prices can change, so check the current menu before ordering.
5. Does Duffer’s have a kids’ menu?
Yes. Duffer’s officially lists a children’s menu, making the restaurant a practical choice for families with younger diners. Dduffers
6. Can I order Duffer’s food and ice cream to go?
Yes. Duffer’s has a dedicated take-out area at the corner of Hildreth and Pacific Avenues. Customers can order in person, by phone, or online, and the take-out menu includes food and homemade ice cream desserts. Dduffers
7. Does Duffer’s take reservations?
No. Duffer’s current official information says it does not take reservations. Guests must be present in person to add their name to the waitlist, and parties larger than six may be split between two booths.
