There are some movies you remember for the story, and then there are movies you remember because the cast is packed with familiar faces. A Good Old Fashioned Orgy is firmly in the second group. Released in 2011, this adult comedy brought together Jason Sudeikis, Leslie Bibb, Lake Bell, Nick Kroll, Tyler Labine, Michelle Borth, Martin Starr, Will Forte, Lindsay Sloane, Angela Sarafyan, Lucy Punch, and several other recognizable performers.
If you searched for the a good old fashioned cast, you are probably looking for more than a quick list of names. You may want to know who played each character, who the main stars were, what the movie was about, who directed it, how critics received it, and what happened to the actors after the film.
That makes the movie especially interesting today. Several members of the ensemble went on to become much bigger names in television, film, comedy, and streaming. Looking back at the cast now gives the movie a different kind of appeal.
This guide covers the main cast and characters, supporting performers, the story behind the movie, release information, critical response, and the careers of some of its most recognizable actors.
Who is in the A Good Old Fashioned Orgy cast?
A Good Old Fashioned Orgy features a large ensemble built around Jason Sudeikis, who plays Eric Keppler, a party-loving man trying to cope with the possible loss of his father’s Hamptons home.
The principal cast includes Jason Sudeikis as Eric, Leslie Bibb as Kelly, Tyler Labine as Mike McCrudden, Lake Bell as Alison Cohen, Michelle Borth as Sue Plummer, Nick Kroll as Adam, Angela Sarafyan as Willow, Lindsay Sloane as Laura, Martin Starr as Doug Duquez, Rhys Coiro as Marcus, Lucy Punch as Kate, Will Forte as Glenn, David Koechner as Vic George, Lin Shaye as Dody Henderson, and Don Johnson as Jerry Keppler.
The movie has a particularly interesting ensemble because many of these actors were already established comedy performers, while others became much more recognizable in later years.
Here is a quick cast overview:
- Jason Sudeikis — Eric Keppler
- Leslie Bibb — Kelly
- Tyler Labine — Mike McCrudden
- Lake Bell — Alison Cohen
- Michelle Borth — Sue Plummer
- Nick Kroll — Adam
- Angela Sarafyan — Willow
- Lindsay Sloane — Laura
- Martin Starr — Doug Duquez
- Rhys Coiro — Marcus
- Lucy Punch — Kate
- Will Forte — Glenn
- David Koechner — Vic George
- Lin Shaye — Dody Henderson
- Don Johnson — Jerry Keppler
Rotten Tomatoes also lists Alex Gregory and Peter Huyck as the directors and screenwriters, with James D. Stern as producer.
The large cast is important because the story depends heavily on relationships between friends. Instead of following one character from beginning to end, the movie constantly moves between different personalities, romances, friendships, and disagreements.
Jason Sudeikis as Eric Keppler
Jason Sudeikis plays Eric Keppler, the central character and the person who pushes the movie’s unusual plan forward.
Eric is a thirty-something party lover who has spent years using his father’s Hamptons house as the perfect setting for large summer parties. When his father decides to sell the property, Eric suddenly faces the end of a lifestyle that has defined much of his adult life.
That setup gives Sudeikis a character who is funny but also emotionally stuck. Eric does not simply want to save a house. He wants to preserve the period of his life that the house represents.
This is where Sudeikis fits the role particularly well. Eric needs to be immature enough to make ridiculous decisions, but he also needs enough charm that viewers understand why his friends continue to follow him.
Sudeikis had already established himself as a major comedy performer by the time the movie arrived. His work on Saturday Night Live helped develop the quick timing and relaxed delivery that became useful in film comedies.
Looking at the movie now is also interesting because Sudeikis’ career later expanded dramatically. His performance as Ted Lasso would eventually introduce him to a much wider international audience.
Eric is therefore one of those early roles that lets viewers see Sudeikis before his biggest television success.
Leslie Bibb as Kelly
Leslie Bibb plays Kelly, a real estate agent connected to the sale of Eric’s father’s house. She becomes an important character because Eric’s relationship with her gradually becomes more personal.
Kelly could easily have been written as a simple obstacle. Eric wants the house to stay available, while Kelly is involved in the process of selling it. Instead, their relationship creates a romantic complication that gives Eric another reason to rethink what he actually wants.
Bibb brings a calmer presence to the story than some of the louder members of the friend group. That contrast works well because Eric and his friends often behave as if the party years should never end.
Kelly, on the other hand, represents the adult world that Eric keeps trying to avoid.
Her character also gives the movie a more conventional romantic storyline. Even though the film’s premise is deliberately outrageous, the relationship between Eric and Kelly gives the audience a more familiar emotional thread.
For viewers researching the cast today, Leslie Bibb is another reason the film is worth revisiting. She had already built a strong screen career before the movie and continued working steadily in film and television afterward.
Tyler Labine as Mike McCrudden
Tyler Labine plays Mike McCrudden, one of Eric’s closest friends and one of the people most willing to support his big idea.
Mike is important because Eric needs someone who will encourage his plans rather than immediately point out how ridiculous they are. That friendship helps move the story forward.
Labine has a natural comic style that works particularly well in group scenes. He can play exaggerated behavior without completely losing the character underneath it.
The friendship between Eric and Mike is one of the movie’s strongest structural elements. Their conversations make the central plan feel like something two longtime friends might genuinely convince themselves is a brilliant idea.
Mike also represents an important part of the movie’s theme. The group knows that their lives are changing, even if they are not ready to admit it. Their final summer at the house becomes an attempt to hold on to the past.
Labine’s performance helps sell that mixture of childish excitement and adult uncertainty.
Lake Bell as Alison Cohen
Lake Bell plays Alison Cohen, another member of the longtime friend group.
Alison is more than a background character in the ensemble. Her relationships and personal decisions become part of the larger emotional story, particularly as the group begins confronting the changes happening in their lives.
Bell brings a dry, controlled style to the role. That helps balance some of the broader performances around her.
This is particularly useful in an ensemble comedy. If every actor played the material at the same level of exaggeration, the movie could quickly become exhausting. Bell’s more grounded approach creates contrast.
Lake Bell also became known for work beyond acting, including writing and directing. That makes her appearance in the film interesting when viewed as part of her broader career.
Her role here reflects the kind of ensemble comedy that was common in the early 2010s, when a movie could bring together actors from television, sketch comedy, independent films, and mainstream studio projects.
Michelle Borth as Sue Plummer
Michelle Borth plays Sue Plummer, Eric’s former girlfriend and one of his longtime friends.
Sue adds an emotional complication to Eric’s life because she has a history with him that goes back much further than his relationship with Kelly.
The character is a good example of how the movie uses its ensemble. The story is not only about the outrageous event at the center of the plot. It is also about what happens when people who have known each other for years realize that their relationships may be changing.
Sue has feelings that complicate her friendship with Eric, and those feelings become more important as the story develops.
Borth handles the character with enough restraint to keep her from becoming just a romantic plot device.
That matters because Eric’s relationship problems are part of the larger theme: the friends are approaching different stages of adulthood, and they cannot all move forward at the same pace.
Nick Kroll as Adam
Nick Kroll plays Adam, one of Eric’s friends.
For modern audiences, Kroll may be one of the most recognizable names in the cast because his career expanded considerably after the movie. He became known for projects such as The League, Kroll Show, and Big Mouth, among many other television and film roles.
In this movie, Kroll contributes to the group dynamic rather than serving as the central character.
That works well for his comedic style. Kroll is particularly effective when he can react to the strange decisions made by other characters while adding his own awkward energy.
Adam is part of the group that has known Eric for years, so his presence helps establish the idea that these characters have a shared history.
The comedy becomes more believable when the actors seem comfortable with one another. Kroll’s performance fits that loose, conversational style.
For fans who discovered him later, watching A Good Old Fashioned Orgy can be a fun way to see an earlier stage of his career.
Angela Sarafyan as Willow
Angela Sarafyan plays Willow, who is part of the extended friend group and is connected romantically to Doug Duquez, played by Martin Starr.
Sarafyan’s role is not as central as Eric’s, but Willow helps give the ensemble another relationship to work with.
That matters because the movie contains several overlapping friendships and romances. The characters are not isolated from one another, and decisions made by one person can affect several other people.
Sarafyan later became widely recognized for her work as Clementine Pennyfeather in Westworld. Her appearance in this 2011 comedy therefore represents an earlier point in a career that would later include more dramatic and high-profile work.
Her performance here is more relaxed and ensemble-focused.
That makes Willow feel like a real part of the group rather than a character inserted only to deliver jokes.
Lindsay Sloane as Laura
Lindsay Sloane plays Laura, another longtime friend in Eric’s circle.
Laura is one of the characters who helps show that the group does not share exactly the same personality or level of confidence.
Her presence becomes particularly meaningful because the friends are approaching the end of a familiar period. Some are comfortable with where their lives are heading, while others are still trying to figure things out.
Sloane had extensive television and comedy experience before appearing in the film. That background helped her fit naturally into a cast where timing and reactions are essential.
One of the better qualities of an ensemble comedy is that not every character needs to behave the same way. The differences between the friends create opportunities for jokes, arguments, misunderstandings, and unexpected moments.
Laura contributes to that variety.
Martin Starr as Doug Duquez
Martin Starr plays Doug Duquez, a law student and aspiring musician who is dating Willow.
Starr’s dry comic delivery makes him a natural fit for this kind of ensemble. Rather than constantly pushing for attention, he often gets humor from the way his character reacts to everyone else.
That style became a recognizable part of Starr’s career.
Before and after this movie, he worked across television and film, eventually becoming especially familiar to audiences through Silicon Valley and his role as Mr. Harrington in Marvel’s Spider-Man films.
His casting is therefore one of the movie’s more interesting details for modern viewers.
The Doug-Willow relationship also adds another layer to the group. It shows that the friends are not simply a collection of single people waiting for the next party. They have jobs, romantic relationships, ambitions, and problems outside Eric’s world.
That makes the story slightly more relatable beneath its outrageous premise.
Will Forte, Lucy Punch, and Rhys Coiro
Will Forte, Lucy Punch, and Rhys Coiro are three more recognizable performers in the ensemble.
Forte plays Glenn, while Punch plays Kate and Coiro plays Marcus. Rotten Tomatoes lists all three among the film’s cast.
Will Forte was already famous for his work on Saturday Night Live. His particular strength is his willingness to fully commit to unusual characters, which makes him a natural choice for a comedy built around awkward situations.
Lucy Punch brings a different energy to the movie. Her career has included numerous British and American comedy projects, and her sharp timing works well in a large ensemble.
Rhys Coiro plays Marcus, who is connected to Alison. His character contributes to the complicated romantic network that runs through the friend group.
These supporting roles demonstrate why the movie’s casting is arguably more memorable than its reputation might suggest. The film brought together performers with very different comedic styles and allowed them to bounce off one another.
Don Johnson, David Koechner, and Lin Shaye
The supporting cast becomes even more interesting when you look at the veteran actors surrounding the younger group.
Don Johnson plays Jerry Keppler, Eric’s father. David Koechner plays Vic George, while Lin Shaye plays Dody Henderson.
Johnson’s role is particularly important to the story because Jerry owns the house that Eric is desperate to keep.
From Eric’s point of view, the property is a place filled with memories. From his father’s perspective, it is an asset that can be sold. That simple disagreement creates the main conflict.
David Koechner brings his recognizable comic energy to the supporting cast. Audiences may know him from Anchorman, The Office, and many other comedy projects.
Lin Shaye has built a long career as a character actor across comedy and horror. Her presence gives the film another experienced performer who can make even a relatively small role stand out.
Together, these actors connect Eric’s youthful social world with the older generation around him.
What is A Good Old Fashioned Orgy about?
At its heart, A Good Old Fashioned Orgy is about a group of friends facing the end of an era.
Eric regularly throws elaborate parties at his father’s Hamptons house. But when his father decides to sell the property, Eric realizes that the group may be losing the place where they have spent so many summers together.
Instead of accepting the situation quietly, Eric decides to organize one final event.
The plan is deliberately outrageous, but the emotional idea underneath it is fairly familiar. The characters are trying to create one last memory before life changes.
Several friends are beginning to settle down, enter serious relationships, or move in different directions. Eric sees the final party as a way to keep everyone together.
That is why the movie works best when viewed as a friendship comedy with an adult premise, rather than simply as a movie built around shock value.
The outrageous event gets attention, but the relationships are what keep the story moving.
Who directed and wrote the movie?
Alex Gregory and Peter Huyck directed and wrote A Good Old Fashioned Orgy. James D. Stern served as producer.
Having the same two filmmakers handle both the screenplay and direction gave the movie a consistent comic voice.
The screenplay has to juggle a large number of characters, which is not easy. Every friend needs enough personality to be memorable, while the central story still has to remain focused on Eric.
Gregory and Huyck built the film around that group dynamic.
The setting also does much of the storytelling work. The Hamptons house is not simply a location where scenes happen. It represents the lifestyle Eric wants to preserve.
Once the house is threatened, the entire social structure surrounding it begins to change.
That gives the comedy a surprisingly recognizable emotional foundation: the fear that your favorite period of life is ending before you are ready.
When was A Good Old Fashioned Orgy released?
The movie was released in 2011, with its limited theatrical release dated September 2, 2011. Rotten Tomatoes lists its runtime as approximately 1 hour and 35 minutes.
It received an R rating for strong sexual content, graphic nudity, and language, so it is clearly intended for adult audiences.
The film arrived during a period when raunchy ensemble comedies were common in American theaters.
Its cast also reflected the comedy landscape of that era. Sudeikis was known for Saturday Night Live, while performers such as Will Forte and David Koechner had strong comedy credentials. Nick Kroll and Martin Starr were also building careers that would become increasingly visible.
That makes the movie useful as a snapshot of early-2010s comedy.
The production may not have become a major blockbuster, but its cast gives it lasting interest.
How was the cast and movie received?
The critical response was mixed.
Rotten Tomatoes currently lists the movie at 37% on the Tomatometer, based on 62 critic reviews, while the audience score is higher at 41%. The site’s consensus criticizes the writing and humor, although individual reviews differed considerably.
IMDb currently lists the movie at about 6.1 out of 10, showing a more moderate audience response.
That split is worth understanding before watching.
If you expect a sophisticated comedy with carefully developed characters, the movie may not meet your expectations. If you enjoy crude adult humor, ensemble casts, and early-2010s comedy, you may find more to appreciate.
Some critics have also pointed to the chemistry between the cast as one of the movie’s stronger qualities.
That observation makes sense. The actors have different comedic personalities, and their interactions give the film much of its energy.
In other words, the cast may be a stronger reason to revisit the movie than its overall critical reputation.
What happened to the A Good Old Fashioned Orgy cast?
This is perhaps the most interesting question for people discovering the film years later.
Several cast members continued to build significant careers after 2011.
Jason Sudeikis eventually became one of television’s most recognizable comedy stars through Ted Lasso. His role as Ted Lasso earned major awards and transformed his public profile.
Nick Kroll expanded from live and television comedy into writing, producing, acting, and voice work. Big Mouth became one of his most recognizable projects.
Martin Starr became widely known through Silicon Valley and his Marvel appearances.
Angela Sarafyan gained major recognition through Westworld.
Will Forte continued working across film and television, taking on both comedic and dramatic roles.
Lake Bell expanded her career beyond acting into writing and directing.
Leslie Bibb continued appearing in movies and television, including larger studio projects.
The careers of these performers make the movie especially interesting in retrospect. In 2011, they were already talented working actors. In the years that followed, several became much more prominent.
That gives the cast a kind of time-capsule quality.
Is A Good Old Fashioned Orgy worth watching for the cast?
If you are considering the movie because of its cast, it can be worth watching, especially if you already enjoy Jason Sudeikis or ensemble comedies.
The strongest reason is the number of recognizable performers packed into a relatively short movie.
You will find:
- Jason Sudeikis
- Leslie Bibb
- Lake Bell
- Nick Kroll
- Tyler Labine
- Michelle Borth
- Martin Starr
- Will Forte
- Lindsay Sloane
- Angela Sarafyan
- Lucy Punch
- David Koechner
- Lin Shaye
- Don Johnson
The movie is not designed for every viewer. Its adult humor, nudity, language, and deliberately provocative premise make that clear.
However, if you enjoy raunchy comedies from the late 2000s and early 2010s, it fits comfortably within that style.
It is also worth watching if you enjoy spotting actors before their later breakthrough roles.
For example, someone who knows Martin Starr mainly from Silicon Valley or Nick Kroll from Big Mouth may enjoy seeing how their comedic styles appeared earlier in their careers.
The same applies to Angela Sarafyan, Will Forte, Lake Bell, and Jason Sudeikis.
Why the cast remains interesting today
More than a decade after its release, the movie’s cast remains its biggest point of curiosity.
The film brought together performers who represented several different parts of the comedy world. There were sketch comedians, television actors, character performers, and established movie stars all sharing the same ensemble.
That mixture gives the movie a different appeal now than it had at release.
Someone watching it in 2011 might simply have seen a raunchy comedy starring Jason Sudeikis. Someone watching it today can see an early-career snapshot of multiple actors who later became much more prominent.
The cast also works because the characters have different relationships with Eric.
Some encourage him. Some challenge him. Some have romantic feelings for him. Others are simply trying to enjoy the last few days of a lifestyle that is disappearing.
That variety keeps the movie from feeling like a one-person comedy.
It also explains why searches for the cast continue to attract attention. People often remember one actor from a later project and then discover that the same performer appeared in this film.
That is the movie’s lasting curiosity factor.
Final verdict on the A Good Old Fashioned Orgy cast
The a good old fashioned cast is much more impressive than someone might expect from a quick look at the movie’s title.
Jason Sudeikis leads the film as Eric, with Leslie Bibb, Tyler Labine, Lake Bell, Michelle Borth, Nick Kroll, Angela Sarafyan, Lindsay Sloane, Martin Starr, Rhys Coiro, Lucy Punch, Will Forte, David Koechner, Lin Shaye, and Don Johnson filling out the ensemble.
The movie itself received mixed reviews, so it would be unfair to describe it as a universally praised comedy. Rotten Tomatoes’ current critic score reflects that.
Still, the cast gives the film a reason to remain interesting.
It captures a particular moment in comedy, when several talented performers were already working steadily but had not yet reached some of the career highs that would come later.
Conclusion
The story is also more relatable underneath its outrageous premise. Eric is trying to hold on to a house, a friendship group, and a carefree period of life that is disappearing. That basic feeling is familiar even if the way he handles it is anything but ordinary.
So, if you searched for a good old fashioned cast because you wanted to know who is in the movie, the short answer is Jason Sudeikis, Leslie Bibb, Tyler Labine, Lake Bell, Michelle Borth, Nick Kroll, Angela Sarafyan, Lindsay Sloane, Martin Starr, Rhys Coiro, Lucy Punch, Will Forte, David Koechner, Lin Shaye, and Don Johnson.
The more interesting answer is that the movie contains a surprisingly strong collection of performers whose careers continued to evolve long after its 2011 release.
For fans of comedy, that makes A Good Old Fashioned Orgy less of a forgotten title and more of an entertaining time capsule.
Frequently asked questions about the A Good Old Fashioned Orgy cast
1. Who is the main star of A Good Old Fashioned Orgy?
Jason Sudeikis is the lead actor. He plays Eric Keppler, a thirty-something party lover who tries to organize one final event after learning that his father’s Hamptons house is being sold.
2. Who plays Kelly in A Good Old Fashioned Orgy?
Leslie Bibb plays Kelly, the real estate agent involved with the sale of Eric’s father’s house. Her character also develops a romantic relationship with Eric.
3. Is Nick Kroll in A Good Old Fashioned Orgy?
Yes. Nick Kroll plays Adam. He is part of the main group of friends surrounding Eric. Kroll’s later career includes Big Mouth, Kroll Show, and numerous other comedy projects.
4. Is Will Forte in A Good Old Fashioned Orgy?
Yes. Will Forte plays Glenn. Forte was already well known for Saturday Night Live and later became a prominent film and television actor.
5. Is Martin Starr in A Good Old Fashioned Orgy?
Yes. Martin Starr plays Doug Duquez. Starr later became especially recognizable through Freaks and Geeks, Silicon Valley, and his appearances in Marvel’s Spider-Man films.
6. Who directed A Good Old Fashioned Orgy?
Alex Gregory and Peter Huyck directed the movie and also wrote the screenplay. James D. Stern was the producer.
7. When did A Good Old Fashioned Orgy come out?
A Good Old Fashioned Orgy was released in 2011, with a limited theatrical release beginning September 2, 2011. It has a runtime of about 95 minutes and an R rating for strong sexual content, graphic nudity, and language.
